Log In

View Full Version : Bombing Gaza - Revenge and Retaliation



zenekar
01-05-2010, 04:27 PM
January 4, 2010

Bombing Gaza - Revenge and Retaliation

By LYNDA BRAYER

Is it an accident that over the past five days Israeli F-16 fighters have bombed Gaza City while tanks and missiles targeted several other areas in the Gaza strip of Palestine? It also appears that the Israelis attempted to assassinate the secretary-general of the PRC, the Palestinian Resistance Committee?* While no one was killed, once again there was extensive physical damage together with the horror of being bombed, a situation which gives rise to profound fears and uncertainty in both the children and adults.

These attacks seem to have been co-ordinated with the timing of the Gaza Freedom March* whose participants had been prevented as a group from approaching Gaza through Rafah to join Palestinians in a solidarity march protesting the continuing siege against Gaza. These attacks also seem to be directed against the Declaration in Cairo of the Gaza Freedom March both condemning the siege and demanding its lifting.* Were these actions targeting Gaza taken both to force the Egyptian government to prevent the big march as well as in retaliation against those who dared to speak out and demonstrate against the continuing Israeli murderous siege of Gaza?*

In other words, has the Israeli regime adopted Rhett Butler's famous/infamous response to Scarlet O'Hara in the novel, Gone with the Wind,* where he turned to her and said “Frankly my dear, I don't give a damn!”* Is *the Israeli regime telling us that the continuing war against Gaza and the throttling of life there are all acts that should not be commented upon, not remarked upon, not to be* condemned?* Not to be noticed?

Despite the constant attempts to prevent any comparisons being made, one cannot help but be reminded of the Zionist/Holocaust voices continuing to condemn the silence ordinary people maintained the face of the mass extermination of European Jewry during WWII.* One cannot help hearing over and over again the accusations against the goys whose silence allowed the Jews to be led to the slaughter without protest of the surrounding populations! Etc. Etc.

For those of us who remember some of the history we have learned, I think that it is not inapposite to focus attention on the fate of the Jewish woman from Breslau, the philosopher Edith Stein, who was one of the main assistants of the philosopher Edward Husserl, a forerunner of Martin Heidegger, who developed the field of phenomenology which grounded one's understanding of life within material existence, rather than in ideal, conceptual notions – an approach to human life not much different from historical materialism.* She converted in 1922 to Roman Catholicism, and taught in Catholic schools and institutes until her decision to enter religious life in 1933, becoming the Roman Catholic Carmelite nun Sister Teresa Benedicta in the Carmel of Cologne, St Maria von Frieden. However, with the rise of the Nazis and the threats to Jews, she and her sister Rosa, who also converted, were transferred to the Carmel Convent in Echt, Holland.*

On July 20, 1942, the Dutch Bishops' Conference issued a statement which was read in all the* churches condemning Nazi racism, and thereby obviously condemning the anti-Semitism of the Nazi regime. In a retaliatory response on July 26, 1942, the Nazi government of occupied Holland, Reichkommissar Arthur Seyss-Inquart, ordered the arrest of all Jewish converts who had previously been spared from deportation. Stein and her sister Rosa were arrested and deported to Auschwitz on August 9, 1942, where they met their death.

Lynda Brayer is an Israeli human rights lawyer who represented Palestinians in the Israeli High Court of Justice for twelve years. She can be reached at [email protected]



_________

"Mad" Miles
01-05-2010, 06:04 PM
Attila,

I strongly support the right of Palestinian Arabs to their own homeland, also supporting the right for Israel to exist. (In spite of the crimes committed in the process of its founding and in its subsequent perceived self-defense.)

But didn't I see in the paper that a rocket was fired from Gaza into Israel? The first in a year since the razing of Gaza by the IDF.

This piece that you forwarded makes no acknowledgment of that.

I agree that five days of bombing and shelling are hugely disproportional to one home made rocket. But the import of this article makes it sound like these attacks are entirely unprovoked. That's not what I heard.

On the other hand I also find it all too distressfully telling that these attacks have not been reported in my local paper, nor in the Sunday NYT's. Not surprising, in fact quite predictable.

But if truth telling is the beginning of understanding, then there's not much hope to be found here.

"Mad" Miles

:burngrnbounce:

Spike
01-06-2010, 11:22 AM
I'm not sure what troubles me most about this contribution. It just may be the motive of the writer.

Anyone with a pen can scribble selective historical facts to generate support for their position. I often quote something I once read on a book's jacket, I fear "the consequences of a world in which the lines between fact and opinion, informed expertise and amaturist speculation are blurred." My fear of the driven intellect blogger is much greater. To me, the author's tone of "Zionist" resonates the same as those who support jihad...with hateful dedication.


"the horror of being bombed, a situation which gives rise to profound fears and uncertainty in both the children and adults."... Quite possibly, the most disturbing statement here. Uninformed readers should know, before they start hating Israel, Israeli's and Jews based on this writer's assertions, that "horror" was first inflicted on the Israel people by anti-Israel Arabs.

Personally, taking a look at the news, I can no longer consider the Israel/Palestinion issue as a regional conflict. I doubt most Americans appreciate that Muslims are good people and the terrorist extremists who call for the destruction of Israel, death to all Jews, the U.S., Salmon Rushdie, that Danish cartoonist and anyone who disagrees with their interpretation of their laws and beliefs, are far removed from the spirit of Islam.

Conflicted about the Israeli/Palestinian issue? Take a look at their respective public school texts and weigh the distinct differences in culture and education. Palestinian kids are taught to hate and kill Jews starting in grade school. Jewish children are not taught to hate and kill Arabs, nor do they use their kids as martyrs. They are trained as a nation to defend their homeland, race and culture.

Israel is far from perfect. The horror for me is that, with all the politics, money and deaths, nothing even remotely close to peace is in sight. Hate ain't going to help that on either side. Personally, I feel the accurate telling of the Palestinian's short history, a telling of the people not the political terrorist organizations that we've seen represent them over a few decades, is much more compelling than changing history.

One last wonder. Is this (former?) lawyer's contribution only for Wacco or is Lynda's campaign web wide?

Spike
01-06-2010, 12:31 PM
Sorry Folks,
My initial response was a little out of context. I have little experience with the different Forum/BBS formats and just figured out this was a reprint. I truly feel this kind of propoganda is dangerous and a major step back for society. The opposing position is just as dedicated.

I know sympathy for the Palestinian cause, especially on a human rights level, is at a popular high. I believe posts like this reprint are cheaply articulated to get sympathetic support for the cause and generate hate. Plain and simple. Personally, I just don't see any upside to propogating this kind of junk and in my experience, most distributors of garbage to the internet don't put any more effort into the causes they promote than cut, paste and send.

"Mad" Miles
01-06-2010, 01:42 PM
Spike,

You wrote: "Uninformed readers should know, before they start hating Israel, Israeli's and Jews based on this writer's assertions, that 'horror' was first inflicted on the Israel people by anti-Israel Arabs.", this shows clearly where you stand on the issues of the Palestinian/Israeli conflict. Many have a better reading of that history.

And for you to malign Zenekar as simply cutting, pasting and posting, without otherwise having contributed to the issue, means that you do not know Attila Nagy (aka Zenekar) and his many years of active contribution to the causes of social justice and tolerance.

If you were a part of the social justice and human rights community in Sonoma County, you would never have made such a claim. Because you would know the person you tried to insult.

As for sympathy for Palestinians being at a "popular high", all I can say is, about fucking time!!!! For all the good it's going to do them given the entrenched power dynamics there.

I pointed out that Zenekar's forwarded piece left out crucial information. Even so, the point its writer makes is well taken and important.

This endemic conflict is a knotty and complex one. It has been slightly discussed in previous threads on this board. There's not much new to say and there're complex differences even within the various enemy camps.

As I see it, the only hope for positive change is a profound self-examination by the majority of Israelis, and their unquestioning supporters in the U.S. and other parts of the west.

A sober look at the history of the founding of Israel, and the war crimes commited since in its purported defense, is a beginning. I can refer you to the work of various revisionist Israeli historians if you're interested.

Unfortunately that is as likely as Americans as a whole (U.S. Americans) taking a serious look at our own history and seeking atonement and forgiveness from the descendents of the victims of our ancestors.

Denial, forgetting and avoidance are so much easier and comfortable. And the resulting answers are so much simpler!

"Mad" Miles

:burngrnbounce: