Zeno Swijtink
10-27-2009, 08:09 AM
How to Teach a Man to Talk Like a Woman (https://newswise.com/articles/how-to-teach-a-man-to-talk-like-a-woman?category=science&page=1&search[status]=3&search[sort]=date+desc&search[section]=20&search[has_multimedia]=)
American Institute of Physics
The talk "Acoustic changes associated with transgender speech therapy: A case study" (1aSC6) by James Dembowski is on Monday, October 26
See: https://asa.aip.org/web2/asa/abstracts/search.oct09/asa39.html
How does the voice of a woman differ from the voice of man? You might think that pitch is the big difference, but according to speech pathologist James Dembowski, you would be wrong. And he should know -- for the last year, he has been working with a middle-aged transgendered woman born as a boy, teaching "Ms. J" to use her male vocal anatomy to speak in a womanly way.
"She did not want a high-pitched voice or some kind of ditzy-sounding voice," says Dembowski, who will be presenting his work at a meeting of the Acoustical Society of America (ASA) next week in San Antonio, TX. "As a successful academic in a local university, she posed an interesting challenge. She wanted to sound feminine but not stereotypical."
When boys reach puberty, rising levels of testosterone change the anatomy of their vocal cords, causing the voice to crack and drop. Older female-to-male transgendered individuals taking hormone supplements experience similar changes. But when a man decides to become a woman, his vocal anatomy stays fixed and old speech habits have to be unlearned.
It's true that men and women do tend to speak at different pitches -- men around 130 hertz, woman around 200 hertz.
But plenty of women also have lower voices, says Dembowski, who has been focusing on other characteristics drawn from the scientific literature. Women, on average, speak slower, while men often have more rasp and croak in their voices. And men tend to emphasize words by speaking louder, while women vary their pitch.
By recording his client as the therapy progressed and analyzing the speech quantitatively, Dembowski has learned that some of the features are easier to change than others.
So does he think that it is possible to teach someone who is biologically male to have a woman's voice?
"Yes, but it takes a lot of work," says Dembowski.
American Institute of Physics
The talk "Acoustic changes associated with transgender speech therapy: A case study" (1aSC6) by James Dembowski is on Monday, October 26
See: https://asa.aip.org/web2/asa/abstracts/search.oct09/asa39.html
How does the voice of a woman differ from the voice of man? You might think that pitch is the big difference, but according to speech pathologist James Dembowski, you would be wrong. And he should know -- for the last year, he has been working with a middle-aged transgendered woman born as a boy, teaching "Ms. J" to use her male vocal anatomy to speak in a womanly way.
"She did not want a high-pitched voice or some kind of ditzy-sounding voice," says Dembowski, who will be presenting his work at a meeting of the Acoustical Society of America (ASA) next week in San Antonio, TX. "As a successful academic in a local university, she posed an interesting challenge. She wanted to sound feminine but not stereotypical."
When boys reach puberty, rising levels of testosterone change the anatomy of their vocal cords, causing the voice to crack and drop. Older female-to-male transgendered individuals taking hormone supplements experience similar changes. But when a man decides to become a woman, his vocal anatomy stays fixed and old speech habits have to be unlearned.
It's true that men and women do tend to speak at different pitches -- men around 130 hertz, woman around 200 hertz.
But plenty of women also have lower voices, says Dembowski, who has been focusing on other characteristics drawn from the scientific literature. Women, on average, speak slower, while men often have more rasp and croak in their voices. And men tend to emphasize words by speaking louder, while women vary their pitch.
By recording his client as the therapy progressed and analyzing the speech quantitatively, Dembowski has learned that some of the features are easier to change than others.
So does he think that it is possible to teach someone who is biologically male to have a woman's voice?
"Yes, but it takes a lot of work," says Dembowski.