Log In

View Full Version : Support Benjamin Saari and your right to observe police activity



Bursts O'Goodness
06-03-2008, 05:46 PM
here is a letter to the DA asking them to drop the charges against Ben
Saari for his unjustified arrest on May 1st. If you can, please either
sign it yourself and send it in or treat it like a petition and gather
signatures and then send it in. Ideally we are trying to send it in asap
(with in the next week or so) so however you can help will be awesome. The
following is the letter. If you have the time and would like to send in
your own letter that would be excellent.

Concerned community members have also made a website concerning Ben's arrest and how to support him. They're hoping to use the site in the future to support others made into prisoners of conscience in Sonoma County. The website is https://www.sonomadefense.org
=============================================================

Stephan Passalacqua

Hall of Justice, Second Floor
600 Administration Drive, Room 212-J
Santa Rosa, California 95403
Telephone: (707) 565-2311
FAX: (707) 565-2762


Mr. Passalacqua,


Hello. I’m writing you to insist that you drop all charges against
Benjamin Saari from his arrest of May 1st, 2008. I believe Mr. Saari is an
upstanding member of our community and that his arrest for publicly
observing police activities in a legal manner is an attack on individuals
and thus the community’s right to safely and critically observe public
servants on the job.

On May 1st, as thousands were entering Santa Rosa’s Juliard Park from the
east side, Santa Rosa police officers began trying to corral youth, mostly
young Latinos, on the west side of the park. SRPD had extended metal
batons at ready and a very agitated police dog. Different squads of
police were yelling conflicting orders at the nebulous group of youth
they’d defined as a gang. I believe that at this point Ben Saari exercised
his ability to observe the police in a manner in keeping with the First
Ammendment right to peaceably assemble. As police advanced on the crowd,
which Mr. Saari was pushed into, Mr. Saari made a point of communicating
with the advancing officers and keeping a safe distance between himself
and the officers.

At one point an officer being most directly observed stepped up his pace
and shoulder-checked Mr. Saari, claiming the contact as Mr. Saari’s
interference with police activities and arresting him for such. The
arresting officer did not immediately announce the charges as Mr. Saari
was arrested, nor was Mr. Saari read his Miranda rights. Mr. Saari
repeatedly asked the officer if he was being arrested and just before Mr.
Saari’s arrest the arresting officer informed Mr. Saari that he was in
fact not being arrested. Mr. Saari was never told by the police or the
police department what he was being arrested for. He was only informed of
his charges when released on bail by the person who posted the bail.

Elements of Sonoma County Law Enforcement, particularly among the Santa
Rosa Police and Sonoma County Sheriff, have been resistant to public
observation of their activities from a safe distance, in some cases not
identifying themselves, obscuring the visibility of interactions or even
threatening the observers with arrest. Many believe this is because the
police fear being observed overstepping their bounds and trampling
people’s rights and because of a law enforcement culture that fears public
oversight.

I believe that community members checking authorities and pushing
institutions towards more transparency deters abuse of power and makes a
community healthier. Local activists should not be allowed to be punished
for legitimately checking authority and attempting to deescalate
potentially explosive situations through their public observation and nor
should they be dissuaded from active participation in matters of public
affair.

The foundations of a free and open society rest upon the active
participation of those living within it’s bounds in the decisions and
running of that society. That is the foundation of democracy. Allowing a
branch of the executive to suppress the legitimate oversight of that
institution by the people affected by its activities leads us further down
the road away from that free and open society and hastens toward rule by a
government with unchecked power.

Again, I strongly encourage you to do the right thing and drop the charges
against Benjamin Saari. Thank you for your time.

Sincerely,

(print and sign your name, followed by your address here)

Lenny
06-03-2008, 08:13 PM
I wasn't there, but how can you claim it was an "unjustified arrest"? And he hasn't even had his day in court? But you are already saying it's wrong?
I can only guess you were there, and after reading your letter, how can you say "thousands" of young folks were entering the park, and then ask the cops give clear, concise orders. Sounds like a melee to me; and knowing the game, a probable action-jackson time. And it sounds like you want more of that kind of action!
OK, sorry. Enough screwing around with you.
You know, your 1930s communist party tactics really are anachronistic and need to be abandoned or kicked in the slats. There are "Latino" gangs out here and being an old "half-breed" myself growing up in the Mission back in the day, I find it gives me enough credibility to tell you to let the cops do their job. Your kind of shit just gets US hurt, feeds US false hopes and deadly poison, and then you go off and laugh at your parties. Stick it, cause you and your stuff ain't worth :2cents:

PeriodThree
06-03-2008, 10:26 PM
I agree more with Bursts O'Goodness than with Lenny, but he has a major point when he asks how we can know it was an unjustified arrest?

Our system of justice is imperfect, but it is only system we have right now. And it is a far better way of determining truth (even with its flaws!) than debating on a mailing list.


You wrote "As police advanced on the crowd,
which Mr. Saari was pushed into, Mr. Saari made a point of communicating
with the advancing officers and keeping a safe distance between himself
and the officers.

At one point an officer being most directly observed stepped up his pace
and shoulder-checked Mr. Saari, claiming the contact as Mr. Saari’s
interference with police activities and arresting him for such." I was not there, but it seems the police treated this is a potential riot situation. In that situation it seems pretty reasonable to me to argue that he was interfering with police activities. You say he insisted on 'communicating with the advancing officers' and he apparently was in the way of officers (even _if_ the officer stepped up his pace-Mr. Saari was in their way).

In theory the argument will be conducted in court, in front of a judge, rather than on a message board.

Best luck to all involved.

Ben Saari
08-10-2008, 01:52 AM
Just a quick update...

It's been over 14 weeks since my arrest.

The DA has filed no charges.

My videotape of the events leading up to my arrest hasn't been returned.

To get more regular updates check: www.sonomadefense.org

Toxic Reverend
08-31-2008, 02:00 PM
Ben Saari said the videotape of the events leading
up to his arrest hasn't been returned. Just as the
family of Jeremiah Chass have been denied access
to evidence regarding his fatal shooting by police.

Might the tape of Ben Saari's arrest show
constitutional and civil rights violations ?

To get more regular updates about Ben's case check: www.sonomadefense.org (https://www.sonomadefense.org/)


FYI:
First they came... - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came...)
"First they came…" is a poem attributed to Pastor
Martin Niemöller (1892–1984) about the inactivity of
German intellectuals following the Nazi rise to power

_________

Police Brutality and Steroid Abuse,
a national epidemic

Roid a Cops - Police shootings, Brutality & Steroid Abuse - WaccoBB (https://waccobb.net/forums/showthread.php?p=63773) - Aug 28"
Big Guns: When Cops Use Steroids Steroid Abuse Can Contribute to Police brutality and influence
the use of "Deadly Force"...
By the The Toxic Reverend We as tax payers put out a lot of cash to train a policeman ...
<cite>https://waccobb.net/forums/showthread.php?p=63773
- 87k

Google search term;
"sonoma county police shooting"
also see;
</cite>Community Concerns About Law Enforcement in Sonoma County, May 2000
<cite>https://www.usccr.gov/pubs/sac/ca0500/main.htm
</cite>______________

Prejudice; Contempt prior to investigation.
Making a judgment before receiving information
relevant to the particular issue on which a judgment
was being made; it came, however, to be widely
used to refer to any hostile attitude towards people
based on their race or even by just judging someone
without even knowing them. Subsequently the word
has come to be widely so interpreted in this way in
contexts other than those relating to race. The
meaning now is frequently "any unreasonable
attitude that is unusually resistant to rational
influence".<sup id="cite_ref-0" class="reference">[1] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prejudice#cite_note-0)</sup>

_________________

<cite>
Blessings,

</cite> The Toxic Reverend
https://www.myspace.com/<wbr>toxicreverend (https://www.myspace.com/toxicreverend)
aka
Justice Is Homeless
https://www.myspace.com/<wbr>justiceishomeless (https://www.myspace.com/justiceishomeless)



I wasn't there, but how can you claim it was an "unjustified arrest"? And he hasn't even had his day in court? But you are already saying it's wrong?
I can only guess you were there, and after reading your letter, how can you say "thousands" of young folks were entering the park, and then ask the cops give clear, concise orders. Sounds like a melee to me; and knowing the game, a probable action-jackson time. And it sounds like you want more of that kind of action!
OK, sorry. Enough screwing around with you.
You know, your 1930s communist party tactics really are anachronistic and need to be abandoned or kicked in the slats. There are "Latino" gangs out here and being an old "half-breed" myself growing up in the Mission back in the day, I find it gives me enough credibility to tell you to let the cops do their job. Your kind of shit just gets US hurt, feeds US false hopes and deadly poison, and then you go off and laugh at your parties. Stick it, cause you and your stuff ain't worth :2cents:

d-cat
09-01-2008, 12:20 AM
Ben - I'd like to get your story some exposure (to an audience of approx 2 million). Please check your private messages.

Police State 2007
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mvHDx8YQk4

Moon
09-02-2008, 08:13 PM
Talk like this shows us what kind of person sides with those in power no matter what they do.


You know, your 1930s communist party tactics really are anachronistic and need to be abandoned or kicked in the slats. There are "Latino" gangs out here and being an old "half-breed" myself growing up in the Mission back in the day, I find it gives me enough credibility to tell you to let the cops do their job. Your kind of shit just gets US hurt, feeds US false hopes and deadly poison, and then you go off and laugh at your parties. Stick it, cause you and your stuff ain't worth :2cents: